Football
Edmilson: Comparing Mbappe to Messi, Ronaldo is not logical
The French international has enjoyed another superb year in Paris, but the Brazilian feels he is still too young to be considered as the world’s best
Paris Saint-Germain attacker Kylian Mbappe is not ready to join Cristiano Ronaldo and Lionel Messi as a Ballon d’Or winner just yet, according to Edmilson Moares.
The 20-year-old finished fourth in the voting for the 2018 edition of the coveted individual award, behind Antoine Griezmann, Ronaldo and eventual winner Luka Modric.
Mbappe became a World Cup winner with France in Russia last year, shortly after completing an impressive debut campaign at the Parc des Princes.
He has kicked on with extra vigour this season, scoring 32 goals in 36 matches across all competitions for PSG, who are on course for yet another domestic double come May .
Unfortunately, their year is likely to be defined by a last-16 Champions League exit at the hands of Manchester United, but Mbappe’s stock still continues to rise with each passing game.
Ligue 1 ambassador Edmilson – who was speaking after watching Strasbourg win the Coupe de la Ligue final on penalties against Guingamp last weekend – feels that it is too early for PSG’s star youngster to be compared with the modern-day greats.
When asked if Mbappe could win this year’s Ballon d’Or, he responded: “No, because of his age.
“He can do great things but Lionel Messi and Cristiano Ronaldo have been doing it consistently for the past 10 years, it is unbelievable.
“You can’t do this kind of comparison today, it is not logical.”
Edmilson did, however, concede that the France international is the best player in Ligue 1 at the moment, even ahead of his PSG team-mate Neymar.
“Today, it is (Kylian) Mbappe,” he added. “He is a world champion, young, fast, playing at a very good level by scoring a lot of goals.
“Thanks to the quality of the players such as Neymar, Cavani, Fekir, Memphis, Ligue 1 can now dream about having good days, which was not always the case before.”
Neymar’s season at PSG was cut short for the second consecutive year after he sustained metatarsal damage in January, which has forced him to sit out the last few months of action.
The Brazilian still harbours ambitions of becoming the world’s greatest player and Edmilson thinks he is capable of achieving that goal, but only if he can overcome his fitness issues.
“Before thinking about the Ballon d’Or, Neymar has to come back, play, score and give good performances,” Edmilson continued. “If he’s doing that, he can be among the best players in the world. Questions linking Neymar and the Ballon d’Or do not help him, PSG or Brazil.
“The most important thing is that Neymar does a complete season with PSG.”
Paris Saint-Germain attacker Kylian Mbappe is not ready to join Cristiano Ronaldo and Lionel Messi as a Ballon d’Or winner just yet, according to Edmilson Moares.
The 20-year-old finished fourth in the voting for the 2018 edition of the coveted individual award, behind Antoine Griezmann, Ronaldo and eventual winner Luka Modric.
Mbappe became a World Cup winner with France in Russia last year, shortly after completing an impressive debut campaign at the Parc des Princes.
He has kicked on with extra vigour this season, scoring 32 goals in 36 matches across all competitions for PSG, who are on course for yet another domestic double come May .
Unfortunately, their year is likely to be defined by a last-16 Champions League exit at the hands of Manchester United, but Mbappe’s stock still continues to rise with each passing game.
Ligue 1 ambassador Edmilson – who was speaking after watching Strasbourg win the Coupe de la Ligue final on penalties against Guingamp last weekend – feels that it is too early for PSG’s star youngster to be compared with the modern-day greats.
When asked if Mbappe could win this year’s Ballon d’Or, he responded: “No, because of his age.
“He can do great things but Lionel Messi and Cristiano Ronaldo have been doing it consistently for the past 10 years, it is unbelievable.
“You can’t do this kind of comparison today, it is not logical.”
Edmilson did, however, concede that the France international is the best player in Ligue 1 at the moment, even ahead of his PSG team-mate Neymar.
“Today, it is (Kylian) Mbappe,” he added. “He is a world champion, young, fast, playing at a very good level by scoring a lot of goals.
“Thanks to the quality of the players such as Neymar, Cavani, Fekir, Memphis, Ligue 1 can now dream about having good days, which was not always the case before.”
Neymar’s season at PSG was cut short for the second consecutive year after he sustained metatarsal damage in January, which has forced him to sit out the last few months of action.
The Brazilian still harbours ambitions of becoming the world’s greatest player and Edmilson thinks he is capable of achieving that goal, but only if he can overcome his fitness issues.
“Before thinking about the Ballon d’Or, Neymar has to come back, play, score and give good performances,” Edmilson continued. “If he’s doing that, he can be among the best players in the world. Questions linking Neymar and the Ballon d’Or do not help him, PSG or Brazil.
“The most important thing is that Neymar does a complete season with PSG.”
-
Business3 days agoOPay explains how Nigerians can access FG’s N50,000 monthly cash relief
-
Sports1 week agoSenegal opens Dakar 2026 Youth Olympic Games, Africa’s first Olympic event
-
Latest1 week agoFG Announces N50,000 cash support for vulnerable Nigerians under new relief programme
-
Business1 week agoNNPC’s N66-per-litre petrol discount set to end October 31
-
Latest7 days agoINEC recognises Pantami for Gombe, keeps Kano NDC candidate off final list
-
Latest1 week agoNetanyahu, Eisenkot face coalition deadlock as Israel struggles to form new government
-
Latest1 week agoNDC Chieftain tells Atiku to drop presidential ambition over son’s support for Tinubu
-
Crime1 week agoDoris Ogala remanded as Court adjourns bail hearing to November 6


